Japan Budget Outlook Turns Negative as Bond Markets React

Source: Coindoo Original Title: Japan Budget Outlook Turns Negative as Bond Markets React Original Link: Japan’s fiscal narrative has shifted again, only weeks after Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi declared that the country was on track to achieve its first primary budget surplus in nearly three decades.

New projections from Japan Cabinet Office suggest that recent stimulus measures have pushed the government back into the red.

Key Takeaways

• Japan is expected to miss its primary balance surplus target, with the latest Cabinet Office outlook pointing to a small deficit despite earlier government optimism.
• The gap comes from heavy stimulus spending and higher local government costs, exposing a mismatch between the narrow budget metric cited by Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi and the broader measure watched by investors.
• Fiscal concerns have unsettled bond markets, with long-term Japanese yields spiking as doubts grow over tax cuts and the sustainability of public finances.

According to the latest mid- to long-term outlook, Japan is now expected to record a primary balance deficit of roughly ¥0.8 trillion in the fiscal year starting in April, equivalent to about -0.1% of GDP. While this would still mark the smallest gap since fiscal consolidation targets were introduced in 2001, it contrasts sharply with the ¥3.6 trillion surplus forecast under the government’s base-case scenario just a few months ago.

Two fiscal yardsticks, two very different pictures

The discrepancy stems from how the primary balance is measured. Takaichi has relied on a narrower metric tied to the initial annual budget, which still points to a surplus. The broader Cabinet Office measure, however, factors in additional spending during the year, as well as outlays by local governments and public funds. This wider definition has long been regarded by policymakers and investors as the true test of Japan’s fiscal health.

Although the prime minister has recently shifted emphasis toward reducing the public debt-to-GDP ratio rather than hitting a primary balance target, the long-standing gap between the two measures is drawing renewed attention as scrutiny of Japan’s finances intensifies.

Bond market jitters resurface

Fiscal concerns have already rippled through markets. Earlier this week, long-dated Japanese government bond yields surged, with 40-year bonds climbing above 4% for the first time since their introduction in 2007. The sharp move reflected investor unease over Japan’s debt trajectory, compounded by Takaichi’s pledge to temporarily cut the sales tax on food to zero ahead of a snap election.

The spike prompted Finance Minister Satsuki Katayama to urge calm, while coordination with international counterparts followed, including outreach from relevant officials. Although yields have since eased, doubts linger about whether the government will be able to restore the sales tax once it is lowered.

Costs still adding up

The broader deficit outlook reflects several major spending pressures. Around ¥5.2 trillion is linked to Takaichi’s economic stimulus package set to roll out in fiscal 2026, alongside roughly ¥1.2 trillion in higher local government spending, largely driven by rising labor costs. Notably, the proposed food tax cut – estimated to cost about ¥5 trillion annually – is not yet included in the Cabinet Office’s projections.

Despite these headwinds, official forecasts still show Japan’s debt-to-GDP ratio gradually declining in the coming years, aligning with Takaichi’s preferred fiscal benchmark. For investors, however, the renewed gap between political messaging and the broader fiscal reality underscores the delicate balancing act facing the world’s most indebted advanced economy.